Rev. Hiram Smith 1838-1842
Rev. E. Parker 1842-1844
Rev. James R. Taylor 1844-1846
Rev. Charles Kellogg 1846-1855
Rev. E. L. Bowing 1855-1856
Rev. Henry Bates 1857-1861
Rev. E. W. Borden 1861-1863
Rev. H. R. Williams 1864-1880
Rev. F. W. Dickinson 1880-1882
Rev. E. D. Kelsey 1882-1884
Rev. M. P. Jones 1884-1886
Rev. Wm. Bradley 1886-1887
Rev. J. Allworth 1887-1892
Rev. Frank J. Estabrook 1892-1895
Rev. E. F. Norton 1895-1897
Rev. Harvey S. Bush 1897-1899
Rev. Milo J. Sweet 1899-1902
Rev. C. W. Jones 1902-1908
Rev. A. E. Woodruff 1908-1909
Rev. George P. Endy 1909-1915
Rev. Frank Davis 1915-1918
Rev. C.E. Taggart 1919-1920
Rev. W. L. Moore 1921-1923
Rev. Edward Humphrey 1923-1924
Rev. J. M. Turner 1925-1934
Rev. E. L. Crystal 1934-1941
Rev. Carl Anderson 1941-1947
Rev. Daniel Boxwell 1947-1961
Dr. James DeKraker (interim) 1961-1962
Rev. Clarke Cochrane 1962-1972
Rev. Richard Dunn 1972-1978
Rev. Alton J. Cressman (interim) Jan. 1978 – Oct. 1978
Rev. Larry Rieck Oct. 1978 – Jan. 2006
Rev. Mark D. Melillo Jan. 2007 – Oct. 2008
Rev. Keith Langley Oct. 2008 – Aug 2017
Rev. Bill King Feb 2018 – Present